The local warns them to leave the city because it is dangerous, warning that something terrible will happen on Yom Kippur, but the friends believe he is insane. On their way to the hostel, they meet a local who believes that he is King David. Sarah becomes infatuated with Kevin and convinces her friend to go to Jerusalem. He suggests that Rachel and Sarah join him on his journey to Jerusalem, and mentions that he wants to spend Yom Kippur there. Kevin is fascinated by religious mythology, especially the Jinns of Islam, the Golem of Jewish mythology, and the undead or zombies, which he believes to all be manifestations of the same evil. On the plane, they meet a fellow American student named Kevin Reed ( Yon Tumarkin). The rest of the movie is taken from the Glass's POV. Sarah is mourning the loss of her deceased brother and her father gives her a Google Glass. In the present, two Jewish American tourists, Rachel Klein ( Yael Grobglas) and Sarah Pullman ( Danielle Jadelyn), plan a vacation to Tel Aviv. The narrator states that the strange events of 1972 were the 'first proof' of a gateway to Hell in Jerusalem. In a final attempt, the woman screams while sprouting leather wings, just before a priest kills her with a derringer.

After failed attempts to cure her, the priests decide they have no choice but to kill the woman.

Her son claims she was calm at first when she returned from the grave to his home, but became violent later, injuring her husband. It is revealed that Jewish, Muslim, and Christian priests were all called to perform an exorcism on a woman who died three days before. In 1972, two priests are called to record an event at Jerusalem.

Jeruzalem movie sellers